Dreaming of a new BMW SUV but unsure whether the agile X1, the versatile X3, or the commanding X5 best fits your lifestyle? Choosing the right luxury SUV can feel overwhelming, especially when weighing features, performance, and budget.
As your trusted auto broker, Cartelligent helps you compare popular SUVs and decide whether to buy or lease an SUV that aligns with your needs. Let’s dive into a detailed car comparison of the latest BMW X1, X3, and X5 to help you find your perfect match.
For this comparison, we’ve configured representative 2025 models based on popular choices among Cartelligent clients:
2025 BMW X1 xDrive28i: this sample is equipped with leather seats and intelligent all-wheel drive. Added features include heated front seats, rear view camera, head-up display and harmon/kardon speakers. MSRP as configured is $41,350.
2025 BMW X3 xDrive28i: leather seats and intelligent all-wheel drive. Features include a panoramic moonroof, heated front seats, rear view camera, head-up display and harmon/kardon speakers. MSRP as configured is $50,675.
2025 BMW X5 xDrive35i: equipped with leather seats, intelligent all-wheel drive and a third row. Features include heated front seats, a head-up display and harmon/kardon speakers. MSRP as configured is $67,475.
(All pricing and specifications are based on current manufacturer data as of July 2025 and are subject to change.)
Feature Showdown: X1, X3, X5 Side-by-Side
To help you visualize the differences, we’ll examine key features of each vehicle.
Power & Efficiency: Which BMW SUV Sips or Soars?
Understanding what’s under the hood can significantly impact your driving experience and daily fuel costs. Here’s how the engines and fuel economy compare:
Key takeaway: The X1 leads in fuel efficiency, making it an excellent choice for commuters and those prioritizing lower running costs. The X5, with its more powerful 6-cylinder engine, delivers robust performance, ideal for drivers who value acceleration and towing capability.
Space for Life: Cargo and Seating in the X1, X3, and X5
Whether you’re hauling groceries, luggage for a road trip, or a growing family, interior space matters. See how these BMW SUVs stack up:
Key takeaway: The X5 offers the most generous cargo space, making it a strong contender for those needing maximum utility. For those who need substantial storage but prefer a more compact SUV, the X3 provides an excellent balance, while the X1 remains surprisingly versatile for its size.
Make it Electric: love the size of the X5 but want to electrify your ride? Click here to read our review of the all electric BMW iX.
Driving with Confidence: Advanced Safety in BMW’s SUV Lineup
BMW prioritizes safety across its entire lineup, offering advanced driver-assistance features designed to protect you and your passengers.
Key takeaway: All three BMW SUVs can be equipped with a comprehensive suite of cutting-edge safety technologies, allowing you to choose the level of driver assistance that provides you with the most peace of mind.
Click here for more information about SUVs with the highest safety ratings.
Which BMW is Your Perfect Fit?
Ultimately, the best BMW SUV for you depends on your priorities:
The BMW X1 is ideal for if you’re seeking a nimble, fuel-efficient luxury crossover with ample cargo space for its class.
The BMW X3 strikes a balance, offering more space and power than the X1 without the larger footprint or cost of the X5, making it a versatile choice for those needing extra utility.
The BMW X5 is for those who prioritize premium comfort and a powerful engine, offering a commanding presence and generous cargo capacity.
Your Cartelligent Advisor can talk you through the pros and cons of each vehicle (and any other brands) to help you make an educated decision. They can also advise on how to trade in your current car or sell your car as part of your new car search or lease.
Ready to Drive Your Ideal BMW SUV?
Whether you’re looking for the best car deals on a new BMW SUV or exploring how to sell your car before your next purchase, Cartelligent offers a streamlined auto leasing service and car buying service designed to get you the best lease offers or purchase price. Discover the best way to buy a car with our expert guidance. Get started online today to ensure a smooth transition and find the best car deals.
